Casting Pattern Ownership: Who Owns the Tooling You Paid For

The tooling you paid for is yours when your contract or purchase order says it is, because payment alone does not settle title. A tooling charge can still leave the foundry as owner if its quotation reserved the tools. A contract that says nothing leaves ownership to be argued on the facts.

This answer covers a pattern set built to your order and held at a US foundry. Each state enacts its own commercial code and the cases below come from single courts, so have counsel confirm the position in your state.

How you paid changes how strong your claim is. A pattern invoiced separately and paid in full gives you the strongest claim. A pattern amortized into the piece price or supplied at no charge gives you a weak claim unless the contract names you as owner.

Whether Paying for a Pattern Makes It Yours

Paying for a pattern does not by itself make it yours. Under Section 2-401 of the Uniform Commercial Code, title to goods passes “in any manner and on any conditions explicitly agreed on by the parties”. A pattern built for your part counts as goods, so look at what the agreement says about it.

A 1977 California tax counsel memo shows how a buyer can pay and still get no title. Customers paid a plastics molder an “engineering fee” for molds, and the molder’s quotation said the tools stayed its property however the buyer paid. Where a customer’s own terms did not address tooling, counsel found the quotation term would govern and no sale of the tooling would have occurred.

That memo is a sales-tax opinion on plastic molds, and it binds no court. A foundry quotation can say the same thing, though, so read the terms on the quote you accepted.

Who Owns the Pattern When the Contract Says Nothing

A silent contract gives neither side the pattern by default. We found no US statute or appellate rule that names a default owner. The result turns on the facts: who holds the pattern, what the paperwork calls each side, and whether the foundry’s terms reached you. The foundry holding the pattern has the advantage.

If your purchase order and the foundry’s quotation disagree, expect to land here too. The California memo treated a purchase order and a quotation with conflicting title terms as leaving the contract silent on tooling ownership.

The only reported decision we found that ruled on ownership under a silent order is Worth Tool & Die v. Atlantis Electronics, a 1965 Texas appeal over dies. The court said possession alone supports an inference of a legal right to possess, and that possession has even been held to be prima facie evidence of ownership. That put the burden of proving ownership on the customer.

The paperwork in that Texas case called the toolmaker a “supplier” of the finished products, which the court read as a sign the toolmaker would own the dies. Those dies were not fully paid for, so the case does not make suppliers the default owners.

Who Owns the Pattern Under Each Payment Model

A pattern paid up front is often treated as yours, and an amortized or no-charge pattern is safest treated as the foundry’s. When the contract is silent, how you paid changes the strength of your claim, but it sets no default owner. A written term overrides it in every case.

Paid Up Front

A pattern paid up front as a separate charge is often treated as the buyer’s, unless a term in the contract says otherwise. Check that the quote and the invoice show the pattern as a separate purchase and that no printed term reserves it to the foundry.

Amortized Into the Piece Price

Treat an amortized pattern as passing to you only when the contract says so, because we found no rule on when it passes to the buyer.

Foundry-Supplied at No Charge

Treat a pattern the foundry supplies at no charge as the foundry’s unless the contract says otherwise, because we found no US rule on it.

What Counts as the Tooling You Own

Ownership covers whatever your contract defines as tooling. A sand casting set reaches well past the pattern. A set built for your part can include these items:

  • Patterns: the pattern or match plate, any loose pieces, and shaped chill patterns.
  • Core equipment: core boxes and, depending on the core, a de-finning plate, assembly fixture, coresetting fixture or gauge.
  • Machining equipment: a machining fixture and special gauges, if the foundry machines the casting.
  • Straightening tools: a straightening die or fixture, if the casting is straightened after heat treatment.

Some equipment used on your casting stays the foundry’s. Core lifting fixtures, grinding jigs, generic chill patterns and certain gauges are often general tools used on many castings. The test is whether the item is limited to your part.

Who Owns the Gating and Rigging the Foundry Adds

The contract decides who owns the gating and rigging. With no term on it, expect the foundry to keep its process design. Two things need separating here: the physical gates and risers mounted on your pattern, and the gating design behind them.

When a pattern leaves a foundry, the foundry will very often remove the gating and risers before it ships. A buyer can claim the physical additions by contract. If your terms and the foundry’s disagree, the result depends on which terms actually formed the contract.

Who Gets the Pattern If the Foundry Closes

The owner gets the pattern if the foundry closes. Holding title does not mean you can collect it straight away.

In the 2008 Michigan bankruptcy case In re Plastech, Chrysler had paid for tooling and had a contract right to take immediate possession. The court still held that the automatic stay reached the tooling, without deciding who owned it. Plastech was an automotive supplier reorganizing under Chapter 11 and still running, so a closed plant may go differently.

When a foundry liquidates under Chapter 7, 11 U.S.C. § 725 has the trustee dispose of property in which someone else has an interest, after notice and a hearing. That gives you a route through the trustee, but it sets no date.