Expect a sand casting pattern to last until its castings fall out of drawing tolerance, because we found no accepted mold count for any pattern material. The mold counts we found on supplier websites come with no stated test basis. An American Foundry Society research report on abrasion testing says it may be dangerous to assume a material will last a certain number of cycles in the foundry based on a wear test.
This covers a pattern you already own and keep at the foundry between orders. Choosing the material for a new pattern is a separate decision.
Without a count, the way to plan repeat orders is to measure wear. Have the foundry scan the proven pattern and rescan it after an agreed number of molds. Budget every year for the repairs that fall to you, because every pattern wears in production.
What Volume Each Pattern Material Is Planned For
Pattern material is planned by castings per year, with wood for very low volumes and metal above 5,000 castings a year.
| Pattern material | Planned annual volume |
|---|---|
| Wood | About 50 castings a year or fewer |
| Plastic | Up to 5,000 castings a year |
| Aluminum or iron | Over 5,000 castings a year |
These bands are annual volumes, not pattern life. Check your order rate against the band of the pattern you own. If your volume has outgrown the band, expect more maintenance and an earlier rebuild.
Count molds as well as castings. Wear comes from each mold made on the pattern, so a layout with several castings in one mold puts less wear on the pattern per casting.
How the Molding Process Changes Pattern Life
Molding pressure shortens pattern life, so no-bake is the gentlest process and automated green sand is the hardest.
- No-bake: This process causes minimal tooling wear, so wood, plastic and metal patterns all work.
- Green sand at lower volumes: Wood is suitable here, but it still wears out faster than metal.
- Automated green sand: These high-pressure lines use metal patterns to withstand the molding pressure.
- Shell molding: The mold cures above 500°F (260°C), so patterns are metal.
What Wears a Pattern Between Repeat Orders
Sand abrasion, handling damage and humidity in storage shorten a pattern’s life across repeat orders.
Sand Abrasion
Sand abrasion erodes the pattern surface, so the pattern and the external dimensions of the casting get smaller. Abrasion in a core box does the opposite: the core gets larger.
A standard paint layer does not slow sand wear. In a published abrasion test on dry foundry sand, painted pine wore 1.88 mm deep and bare pine wore 1.53 mm deep at 20,000 roller rotations. It was a pilot study with one sample per material.
Handling Damage
Patterns are heavy and awkward to move, so handling leaves scrapes and nicks on the pattern, cracked or broken wooden risers, and worn or broken core box pins. All of this has to be repaired before the next run.
Storage Between Orders
Idle storage changes the size of a wood pattern. Wood swells as it absorbs moisture from humid air, and it can split and crack when it dries out over long storage.
A 300 mm flat-sawn mahogany section moving from 6% to 10% moisture content can change by about 2.2 mm across the grain. That figure is an upper limit for unrestrained solid wood. Laminated pattern stock and a sealed surface move less.
When to Repair and When to Replace
Repair a worn pattern while normal maintenance keeps its castings within drawing dimensions. Replace it when staying in tolerance takes high levels of maintenance. We found no published figure for that line, so agree it with the foundry’s engineers.
Measure the wear to make that call. Once the pattern is proven, have the foundry 3D scan the pattern, its gating system and all core boxes. Agree an inspection interval in molds with the foundry’s engineers, and rescan at each interval.
Set the wear between two scans against the tolerance left on the drawing. That gives you a mold estimate for your own pattern. Treat that estimate as an upper limit, because wear speeds up as the surface roughens.
Who pays depends on the cause:
- Day-to-day repair and upkeep: The foundry pays.
- Severe damage: The OEM and foundry often negotiate the cost, depending on the cause.
- Worn-out pattern: The OEM pays for the replacement.
Budget annually for the repairs that fall to the OEM: severe damage and worn-out patterns. In a casting cost estimate, carry that annual budget instead of dividing the pattern price by a mold count.
Decide before you release the next order, because a new pattern adds to casting lead time. If the pattern has no scan history, have the foundry check the latest castings against the drawing and take the first scan before the run.
